The mandating of masks during Melbourne’s COVID-19 second wave in July 2020 was the single-most important control measure and “turned the epidemic around”, new world-leading Burnet Institute research shows.
The study, published in the journal PLOS ONE, highlights the effectiveness and critical importance of masks as a key tool to prevent community spread of the highly infectious Delta variant in Australia and globally.
Co-lead author Dr Nick Scott said the introduction of mandatory mask use by the Victorian Government on 22 July 2020 while Stage 3 restrictions were in place, turned an exponential increase in community transmission into an exponential decrease, almost overnight.
“We had a unique situation in Melbourne where masks were made mandatory as a single policy change, and compliance went from low use to very high use of masks in the community very rapidly,” Dr Scott, Head of Burnet’s Modelling and Biostatistics Group, said.
“What we saw was a significant 20-30 percent reduction in the effective reproduction rate that correlated with that policy, so it turned the epidemic around from case numbers that were increasing every day to a situation where we could see the numbers were getting back under control.”
The study utilised thousands of images from The Age newspaper photo library of Melbourne community settings which showed mask usage rose from 43 percent before 22 July, to 97 percent after.
This matched almost perfectly with survey data from the SCRUB study led by collaborators at Monash University where, three days before the policy change, 44 percent of participants reported ‘often’ or ‘always’ wearing masks, compared to 100 percent ‘always’ four days after masks were made mandatory.
Study reveals #mask rule turned Melbourne’s second wave. "Masks have a direct impact in stopping people from spreading the virus and stopping other people from getting the virus if they’re in an area where it’s been spread," said co-lead author @AllanSaul7https://t.co/2LlB4c9izt
Study co-lead Professor Allan Saul said the policy change provided researchers with a unique opportunity to examine in real time the impact of masks in a community setting – a city of more than five million people – rather than clinical settings.
“The introduction of masks was the single most important control measure that took place last year in bringing Melbourne’s second wave under control,” Professor Saul, Burnet Senior Principal Research Fellow (Honorary), said.
“It was the critical step that turned it around.”
Professor Saul said the recent emergence of the Delta variant means that masks are even more important now than they were 12 months ago.
“Masks have a direct impact in stopping people from spreading the virus and they stop other people from getting the virus if they’re in an area where it’s been spread,” he said.
“Just as importantly, the fact that you’ve put the mask on reminds you every time you walk out the door that you’re walking into an area where the virus can be transmitted, so there’s an indirect effect of masks which can emphasise the seriousness of the situation.”
Dr Scott said at a time when some Australians may be experiencing lockdown fatigue or apprehension, this study provides evidence that mandatory masks are a tool that can be effective against COVID.
“This is important, because they’re not that invasive when compared to some of the other restrictions that need to be applied to control COVID,” Dr Scott said.
“The fact that we can get real benefit from something that has minimal impact on people’s lives is really important.”
Study co-author, Burnet Institute Director and CEO Professor Brendan Crabb AC said: “Because of the way the policy was introduced, this study remains one of the most powerful examples of masks impacting significantly on community transmission in a major metro setting. In Australia, it is the only such study. The policy includes masks outdoors, we now know how well this works. We simply don’t know if an indoor-only policy works as well.”
Study co-author, Burnet Institute Deputy Director, Professor Margaret Hellard AM said: “The key finding from this study is that masks work. They are an effective way to reduce COVID-19 transmission in the community. Whilst using masks doesn’t mean that other restrictions to stop transmission may not be necessary, their use is a simple first step in our response to an outbreak. Also, whilst we are confident that masks are highly effective indoors, we don’t know how much more effective they are indoors compared to outdoors. Importantly given the growing evidence of outdoor transmission of the delta variant, it makes sense that masks are worn both indoors and outdoors during a COVID-19 outbreak.”
This study was conducted in collaboration with researchers from The Kirby Institute (University of NSW) and Monash Sustainable Development Institute (Monash University).
This website was developed with the generous support of a donor.
Burnet Institute (Australia) is located on the traditional land of the Boon Wurrung people and we offer our respects to their Elders past and present. We recognise and respect the continuation of cultural, spiritual and educational practices of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples of this land.
It looks like something may have gone wrong, and some of the resources required to load the page may not have loaded correctly.